New Models

-
I have no doubt that as we go forward trying to understand our country and make it better we are going to have to find new language, new maps, new models to understand. I have come across one that isn't perfect, but worth considering. 

First, why do we need new models? No model explains everything, they are shorthand to allow collaboration and passing torches for giant projects like cultures and nations. The reason to change out your model is if another one comes along that explains more of the problems with the model ... the ways in which the model doesn't apply or work. 

Ok, so our current model/large-scale narrative is that our society is not perfect, but it is built on equality and freedom. People come to America for this opportunity. Immanuel Wallerstein calls this universalism:
  • jobs assigned/granted by merit
  • school acceptance by merit
  • marriage for love (not wealth or ethic group)
  • equal vote
  • equal before the law
This is the "official gospel of modernity." 

The opposite of that is anti-universalism and includes racism, sexism, bigotry, its-who-you-know, police harassment and brutality, unequal before the law based on wealth/status, etc. 
So Wallerstein says both universalism and anti-universalism are "operative day to day, but they operate in different arenas." He uses a term - cadres. Cadres for him represents the manager class that is "neither in the top command positions of the social system nor among the vast majority who fulfill the bottom tasks." He argues that universalism happens primarily among the cadres group, but that anti-universalism happens everywhere else. 

I am not sure know enough to decide whether his model works and it is set inside a much larger model called World-Systems Analysis Theory. 

Here is why I share it and what does seem useful. We have to find some way to talk about the US ideals/hopes/goals and how those are offered very unevenly to society. I think conservatives always argue that while this is true, it is only a small portion of society being harmed and all other systems will create larger harms or larger groups being harmed. We need to find a way to examine this claim. 

*World-Systems Analysis: And Introduction. Immanuel Wallerstein. 2007.
**Drawing pictured above from The New Way Things Work. David Macaulay. 1998.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Intellectualized Racism is Still Racism

-
Image
John Eastman wrote an opinion piece in Newsweek on Aug 12th 2020 asking questions about Kamala Harris's right to run as Vice President. Eastman is actually arguing what he wishes/wants to the law to say: that you are only a citizen by birth if your are parent was a citizen, AKA he is questioning birthright citizenship. Birthright citizenship is one of the unique things about America and it massively contributes to our diversity as a nation.  It is also born out of the racist maneuvering of the laws around slavery. The famous Dred Scott case of 1857, which contributed to starting the civil war, resulted in a 7-2 decision that African American Dred Scott had no claim because he was not a citizen. In an opinion written by Supreme Court Chief Justice Roger Taney, the court ruled that black people "are not included, and were not intended to be included, under the word 'citizen' in the Constitution, and can therefore claim none of the rights and privileges which that instrum
Read more

The Hearth

-
Image
"A stove used to furnish more than mere warmth. It was a focus, a hearth, a place that gathered the work and leisure of a family and gave the house a center. Its coldness marked the morning, and the spreading of its warmth the beginning of the day. It assigned to the different family members tasks that defined their place in the household. The mother built the fire, the children kept the firebox filled, and the father cut the firewood. It provided for the entire family a regular and bodily engagement with the rhythm of the seasons that was woven together of the threat of cold and solace of warmth, the smell of wood smoke, the exertion of sawing and of carrying, the teaching of skills and the fidelity to daily tasks." (Albert Borgmann: Technology and the Character of Contemporary Life ) So what is our new center? Warmth is now provided in a completely uniform way requiring no demands on our skill, strength or attention. In fact, the warmth device (central heating system) is c
Read more

Lack of Empathy from Liberals

-
I just finished a book which I don't want to name. It was by a really good parent and about parenting children with neurodifferences. It had great information and ideas in and and it came recommended to me by close friends who I love and respect and who are also exceptional parents. So I really don't have anything to say about the content of the book or the need for the book.  It was the tone. It was clear from many references this person was a certain type, an NPR listener, someone who used  to drink diet coke, fluent in a million cliches, etc. This type could be narrowed to white liberal, but lets just stick with liberal for the moment. One major beef liberals (which I consider myself in the completely impoverished terms we have for ourselves in this country) have with conservatives, is how narrow-minded they are and how they refuse to see various perspectives and have empathy for people who are different than themselves. Liberals typically wear the love of difference on thei
Read more